Wednesday, August 04, 2010
That’s Not Right
I was going to lead this story with something like this: “I found myself wondering if they had been inspired by So You Think You Can Dance.” Then I realized that it doesn’t really fit my mood right now; not that there isn’t room for humor, but that it isn’t how I want to see this story today. So, instead, this:
I continue to insist that I not only can judge other cultures, but I must judge them so that we maintain a clear-eyed understanding of what distinguishes us from them. We’re told we aren’t supposed to judge and we aren’t supposed to think in terms of us and them--I know this because, like the rest of you, it has been hammered into me from the time I was a child.
It just isn’t done. The problem is that what we were taught is wrong. It is vital for us to be honest and open about other cultures in the world--not in deifying or demonizing those cultures, but in being earnestly critical in the same way that I hope we consider our own culture and politics. With that said, imagine what I think about the culture that gives us a news story like this:
A group of young Muslim men have been publicly flogged in Sudan after they were convicted of wearing women’s clothes and make-up.
The court said the 19 men had broken Sudan’s strict public morality codes.
Police arrested them at a party where they were found dancing “in a womanly fashion”, the judge said.
We need to judge because we need to constantly remind ourselves of what it is that we value as a society and what it took to create something as grand and diverse as the United States of America.

Comments & Trackbacks
Admit it, if the news article said they were dancing to Broadway showtunes, you would have been less sympathetic to them ...
"Thou shalt not judge” is logically incoherent. In my culture, there is an imperative to judge the cultures of others. Telling me that I shall not do this would violate the prohibition on judging other cultures.
I’m rather a fan of General Napier’s response to sati (or “suttee"):
“You say that it is your custom to burn widows. Very well. We also have a custom: When men burn a woman alive, we tie a rope around their necks, and we hang them. Build your funeral pyre; beside it, my carpenters will build a gallows. You may follow your custom. And then we will follow ours.”
Absolutely right. Wonderful quote.
Moral relativism is utterly antithetical to the concept of universal human rights. It is a justification for racism, sexism, homophobia, and other assorted bigotry.
There’s no excuse for flogging people who are into Priscilla Queen of the Desert, I don’t care if it is camp.
DF, you have the right of it, and that’s what makes me angry when I am faced with people who tell me that I can judge other cultures.
Yes. Yes, I can.